Why It’s Time You Jumped On Peer-to-Peer Recognition Programs

Why It’s Time You Jumped On Peer-to-Peer Recognition Programs
Photo by krakenimages / Unsplash

To stay ahead of the game in today's job market, creating a workplace culture that values employee recognition is a must. It's no longer a luxury.

When you show your employees that you appreciate and value their hard work, you're creating a culture of gratitude and connection that can attract and retain the top talent out there.

But this recognition needn't only come from the top. Peer-to-peer recognition is also a powerful way to improve employee retention and company culture.

Collaborative Meeting
Photo by Redd F / Unsplash

What is a peer-to-peer recognition program?

Starting a peer recognition model is an excellent way for co-workers to express their appreciation and receive more frequent recognition. Rather than waiting for big occasions to hear from senior leadership, they allow everyone to nominate and acknowledge peers for their hard work, contributions, and achievements.

An employee recognition program can take many forms:

  • A bulletin board where people can add notes recognizing employees.
  • A formal rewards program with nomination forms, award ceremonies, and prizes.
  • The use of an employee recognition platform or tool.
Ideas waiting to be had
Photo by Kelly Sikkema / Unsplash

The benefits of employee appreciation & recognition

When you create a culture of recognition, employees are more engaged, motivated, and satisfied with their jobs. This comes with tons of benefits for employers, too, including improved productivity, higher quality work, and better overall performance.

But showing your employees love and appreciation isn't just a feel-good thing—it's also vital for your business and keeping employee turnover low.

When people feel valued and supported, they're likelier to stick around because team morale is that much better. But if you don't give them the recognition they deserve, they might feel disengaged or even jump ship to find greener pastures.

In short, a recognition-rich culture is hugely beneficial to everybody!

How to launch an effective peer recognition program

So, you've decided to launch a staff recognition program—fantastic! There are just a few steps you'll want to take to ensure its success.

thank you message, envelope and red tulip flower on wooden background.
Photo by Towfiqu barbhuiya / Unsplash

First, establish clear goals & your program's objectives

You need to do more than improvise to see a real positive impact and ensure your entire team gets involved. If you're only half in, your other employees' engagement in the program will be too.

So, make sure you…

  1. Decide why you're implementing the program.
  2. Choose who can be recognized and for what.
  3. Set specific, measurable goals.
  4. Determine how often and in what way recognition will be given.

Choose an appropriate recognition platform or tool

You'll find many peer-to-peer platforms on the market these days. They make it easier for employers to monitor and encourage employees to participate. Popular options include…

Bonusly - allows employees to give and receive points that can be redeemed for rewards.

Kudos - enables employees to recognize peers with badges, points, and rewards.

Limeade Listening - a recognition platform that allows employees to give anonymous positive feedback and recognition to their colleagues.

Achievers - offers peer-to-peer name recognition tools, rewards, performance metrics, and analytics.

WooBoard - enables employees to give and receive public recognition through digital boards and personalized messages.

WorkTango - provides peer-to-peer recognition, rewards, and engagement solutions for teams.

Communicate the program to employees & provide training

Make sure you let everyone know what the program's about and why it's so great (remember, if you're lukewarm, everyone else will be too). Then, train employees on how they can participate.

Get people excited and engaged by promoting the program and providing ongoing support. And, of course, remember to check in on how it's working and make any necessary changes along the way.

Group training for peer-to-peer recognition program
Photo by Jason Goodman / Unsplash

Establish guidelines & criteria for nominations and awards

Think about specific achievements or behaviors to be recognized, standards for the awards, how often they can be given, transparency in the selection process, and appropriate rewards for the level of recognition.

Maybe you have awards for the biggest team player, who made your week better, or the greatest problem solver. Really, you can do any category you like—the more fun and personalized, the better, and the more attraction the peer recognition program is likely to receive.

Peer-to-peer recognition ideas & awards

We recommend varying awards. For more frequent prizes, i.e., weekly or monthly, gift hampers or gift cards are a nice touch. For more significant occasions, such as quarterly or annual awards, you could treat a team to dinner or a fun activity.

If you're unfamiliar with our team events here at Yaymaker, we have an option for everybody, ranging from the original Paint Nite to virtual murder mysteries. Plus, you can choose from in-person, hybrid, and virtual events!

Paint and sip team building event with Yaymaker

Evaluate and refine the program regularly

It's easy for the initial excitement to wear off of any scheme. So keep reviewing what people like and adapting your rewards system to keep every team member engaged.

Perhaps the categories aren't interesting enough, the awards aren't motivating—or maybe you've nailed it on the first go, and people can't get enough. Either way, you want to know and understand what the general thoughts are. The goal is for your entire organization/team to get involved.

Tips for a successful peer-to-peer recognition program

Now that we've nailed how to start your program, let's run through recognition best practices.

Encourage participation & engagement from all employees

If you struggle to get your whole team to participate, try evaluating and refining the recognition program. Also, make sure the nomination process is easy to understand and accessible.

Sometimes you need to recognize employees simply for participating—maybe you incentivize them by letting them leave 30 minutes early on a Friday or getting a sweet treat!

Find a way to empower employees and make it worth their while because, ultimately, employee morale will improve with more recognition.

Photo by Brooke Cagle / Unsplash

Ensure fairness & consistency in the nomination & award process

Remember the guidelines and criteria we established earlier? Stick to them and make sure they're known. You don't want people getting salty and feeling like peer recognition is random.

By giving examples and evidence of the nominee's hard work or contributions, you can show that selections are just and the standard to win an award. To make it even fairer, you can have a review process, like an informal committee, to ensure everything's on the up and up.

Teaching employees how to use the program and regularly checking in to see how it's going can help keep things fair and relevant. And don't forget to make sure the program meshes with your company values, so it can help reinforce the right kind of behavior.

Recognize & reward a variety of achievements & contributions

Keep in mind how different people's roles and strengths are. It's essential everyone has the chance to receive recognition.

Consider creating different categories, such as teamwork, innovation, customer service, or leadership. You could even do team-specific rewards, which are a terrific way for the broader office to understand better what everybody does.

Joyful team working together and laughing around a laptop.
Photo by Jud Mackrill / Unsplash


At the end of the day, who doesn't love a good pat on the back? And that's precisely what peer-to-peer recognition programs do for your team. Not only do they show your employees that their hard work is appreciated, but they can also boost morale and create a real sense of community.

As a business owner, you know that keeping your team motivated and happy is crucial to success. So why not give peer-to-peer recognition a try? Your team will feel the love, and you'll reap the rewards!

Here is a quick recap of the benefits of peer recognition programs:

  • Better employee engagement
  • Higher job satisfaction and a happier work environment
  • Performance improvement
  • Lower turnover